RELATED:Modern Family: 10 Things You Forgot From The First Episode. Yeah, he truly loved her from the start. You would think it would be the opposite. Really? It can be hard to pin down every single reason why the seventh season of the show has been so disappointingis it just a natural sitcom regression, or is it something more specific to Modern Family? Her dad might even try abortion seeing how uncomfortable he was with Mitchell's sexuality & upto the point to his wedding. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. I dont know if Im the only one who finds this very inconsiderate of Phil, even if it is presented as a lasting joke in the show. RELATED:Modern Family: The 10 Best Halloween Costumes On The Show. Claire and Phil Dunphy are the cutest couple on Modern Family. Claire Dunphy may be a bit of a control-freak and Phil Dunphy may be pretty happy-go-lucky, but these two make a perfect couple. When Claire told Phil, he brushed it off and said it was totally fine. Cookie Notice RELATED:Modern Family: 5 Sitcom Tropes It Uses (& 5 It Avoids). In the episode, Phil is about to meet with his ex-girlfriend, Denise, who he keeps talking with via Facebook. does phil cheat on claire in modern family. His mimicking of Claires routine, including fake frosting of cupcakes, was pretty hilarious. Its a ridiculously lackluster payoff after such a manic, mysterious build. Claire and Phil had a toxic marriage in some ways, though, because they often wanted the other person to change. Modern Family has typically crafted its comedy out of character-based situations, meaning that the trouble Cam and Mitchell get themselves into is unique to their character history and traits. However, Claire was working to the bone and felt like she was ignoring Phil. Every single scene of them together just gives me butterflies. But this was not just a one-off thing, theyve both worked towards undermining each others parenting behavior quite acutely but this doesnt make sense when they work so hard at co-parenting their three difficult children. Theyre amazing human beings that are even more amazing together. Shes embarrassed by their elaborate dance routines, so shes been turning down weddings for them. RELATED:Modern Family: 5 Ways The Pritchetts Are Exactly Alike (& 5 Ways They're Different). Modern Family fans first met Phil and Claire once they were already married with three kids. They also found out that Haley had photos in an exhibition, which was a proud moment for them as she took a while to find herself. Claire (Julie Bowen) has been accusing Phil (Ty Burrell) of being incapable of scaring her, but this year, Phil pulled out all the stops and planned a scare . She lives in Toronto with her husband and has a special interest in teen dramas, reality TV, and horror movies. Modern Family: 5 Worst Things Claire Did To Phil (& 5 Phil Did To Claire), Modern Family: The Worst Thing Each Main Character Has Done, Modern Family: 10 Fictional Families Who Are More Dysfunctional Than The Dunphys, Modern Family: The 10 Best Halloween Costumes On The Show, Modern Family: 10 Times Phil Embarrassed His Kids, Ranked, Modern Family: Funniest Halloween Episodes, Ranked, It's True, Matt Smith's Post-Doctor Who Success Breaks A 60-Year Trend, The Last Of Us Episode 6 Was A Stealth Reunion For Beloved 90s Sitcom, 6 Possibilities For Who Entered The Room In Criminal Minds' Finale. (I get if youre not a fan of Claire though, she can be uptight but overall I loved her, and I think everyone loves Phil) I started watching Modern Family over a year ago and right when I started watching I couldnt help but think how great Phil and Claire are as a couple. It seems that Rainers excuse of needing to go to the weather station is not true. Does anyone else love Phil and Claires relationship? Phil came back broken-hearted because Claire ruined his hard work. In the season1 episode "RunFor Your Wife," it was time for everyone to go back to school, and that meant that Claire had some alone time during the day. But during their trip with Cam and Mitchells good friend Sal (Elizabeth Banks), Haley sees Rainer spending time with another woman. Claire and Phil had dinner with Tad, who could be one of Phil's real estate clients. They all recognize that theyre trying to hide something, and rather than try to reprimand each other they just let everyone carry on with their secrets. Sign up and stay up to date with our daily newsletter. The 9 to 5 alum, who is Miley's godmother, teamed up with both Billy Ray . Reply Euphoric_Program2980 3 mo. If Phil and Claire wanted to try new things in their marriage to spice things up, why would they return to their role-playing aliases every year? While they could definitely be silly sometimes, Phil and Claire really loved each other and appreciated all the moments that they got together, and this was a perfect example. After that, life got in the way . Mitchell will be there but he might also not like that Claire dumped Phil as Phil might be among few of her boyfriends who was nice to him. For once, Claire felt not needed by her husband and was questioning how much time she was putting in the office. They generally enjoys each others company. This sitcom marriage works because he's a silly goof and she loves to organize everything in sight; they balance each other out. Neither did she ask Jay to make an effort to make Phil better about himself and nor did she talk to Phil about not outdoing herself just to impress Jay. RELATED: Modern Family: 10 Things That Make No Sense About Haley & Dylan's Relationship But there are so many things about their relationship that simply don't add up. Heres what we know about ABCs comedy series. It took her six months or more( the way she said it "six months?!) Just because a relationship starts under weird conditions doesnt mean it cant evolve and become the best version of itself. Phil never mentioned spandau ballet in their entire marriage but she thought this was his fav. RELATED:Modern Family: 10 Fictional Families Who Are More Dysfunctional Than The Dunphys. Even though they have to face the challenges of parenting in the era of social media. He ran over Phil's foot, threw a plane to his head. While Claire and Phil sometimes hurt each other, they could also be the best of friends. Theres Gloria immediately sitting up and shouting what the hell are you doing? when Jay tries to feed one of her dishes to the dog, and Alex immediately guessing porn when Luke and Manny say theyre having a problem with Glorias laptop. As long as both people have respect and patience with each other can last. So no. To be fair, she has put up with a lot of his hijinx over the years. Then she will get charged with Malva's dying, however Tom steps in and confesses to killing Malva to guard Claire. Phil was the one who begged her. But he was dating denise then & had trouble breaking bad news he couldn't break up with denise instantly. There have been numerous instances where they lie to each other when they have no reason to, and when their lie is discovered, they simply dont talk about wanting a more transparent relationship, which is strange considering they wanted an honest relationship. In an attempt to regain some control over his life, he impulsively buys a sports car. Claire is worried about lots of things and Phil is the funny support she needs. According to Claire, Phil was also different prior to the pregnancy. The first trailer for his star-studded new movie Air was released earlier this month and showed off the all-star cast, which also includes Jason Bateman, Chris Tucker and. In an amazing episode called "Farm Strong," Phil and Claire grew tired of going to Luke's soccer games because he usually rides the bench. You got downvoted cuz you seem to come looking for a pathetic excuse to defend on Clair (Phil has always been goofy as hell, since she met him). band. . Their marriage lasted all 11 seasons of the show and presumably forever after. I don't think Claire would get much support from her family specially her mother. Then, when they rule out the fact that they cause an emotional scene everywhere they go, its revealed that its Lily whos been sabotaging their potential weddings. Id argue that you could. Claire has a secret rendezvous in one of the most romantic cities in the world. Copyright 2023 Endgame360 Inc. All Rights Reserved. Now thats doing your business in luxury. It's obvious Phil loves Claire and adores his role as a dad to three kids. During the Hawaii episode, however, Phil Dunphy tried to turn their vacation into a honeymoon. But I always see their relationship as akin to an arranged marriage. Not knowing she had additional help (yet), it made Phil feel belittled and not good enough as a father. This proved that Phil didn't always take his wife seriously, and this seems like a big problem with their relationship. Their opposite personalities and distinct parenting styles made their marriage harder than it needed to be. Aya Tsintziras is a Senior Writer at Screen Rant who enjoys writing about TV and movies. Elsewhere, Phil (Ty Burrell) is worried that his marriage to Claire (Julie Bowen) is in jeopardy. In the season1 episode "Hawaii," the family went on a fun vacation, and Phil had a surprise up his sleeve. Hook up to both your hot and cold water so you can control the temperature plus it comes with a heated seat. He sprayed her with a fire extinguisher. Putting aside his weird crush on Gloria, Phil truly loved Claire. While they didn't want to have frustrating and loud neighbors, Phil knew that he couldn't lie about an offer. While Phil had a soft spot for Luke and the two were similar in many ways, he definitely loved all his children equally. RELATED:Modern Family: Why Alex Is Actually The Show's Main Character. At the end of the day, its certain that Jay and Gloria will be able to patch up their differences like they always do. I personally think it just highlights that men are men and that you can't always be insecure. It seemed like he should have given her some space and let her continue with her routine, so this suggested a breakdown in communication and understanding. Claire later found out the truth and the three of them had a laugh, but it was still sketchy of Phil to hide something like that from his wife. However, he wasn't talking about role-playing with Claire he was talking about a virtual reality game he wanted to play by himself. The reality about Malva's being pregnant is ultimately revealed, and it's fairly the shocker. Claire knew how much those ducks meant to Phil. Claire's all I got. Its not that Phil thinks Claire is cheating, but rather he cant understand how she gets everything done. Press J to jump to the feed. edgewater hotel haunted; can uk consultant doctors work in usa; is spitfire a compliment Lynn is a nomad who travels the globe on the hunt for her next adventure with her husband. I didn't see the relationship as forced or trapped at any point. Did they go to the same college? When he felt Claire is upset about Denise he invited her home. The series is not realistic and consistent enough to insert a dark twist like that. They pretty much got together because Claire got pregnant. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. This ABC comedy series has since come to an end. Also yes, sometimes she wants to feel still young and attractive. RELATED:Modern Family: The Worst Thing Each Main Character Has Done. I doubt it. He bought a sports car without telling her. Phil soon learned of Claire's plan, which made Claire look evil because he was trying to plan out a few romantic days with his wife while she was trying to get rid of him. Both Claire and Phil Dunphy attended college, but they didnt go to the same university. Aya has been a freelance writer since 2014 and has written about topics ranging from pop culture to travel, parenting, and dating and relationships. I think all of the couples have good chemistry but Julie and Ty were phenomenal. However, in one particular episode, Claire realizes that Phil may be more attracted to Julianna than to her. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. While Modern Family's Claire and Phil Dunphy may be polar opposites, this married sitcom couple truly loves each other and are great parents together. When it was time for Haley to think about higher education, he took her on a tour of his school, even showing her the cafeteria trays that he used to slide down. Their love for their children made it work. Alex went to CalTech for biochemistry and Mitchell attended Cornell University and Columbia University to get his law degree. They really have amazing chemistry. He even looks like Agnes from Black Christmas #ModernFamily" while another added, "Holy shit, Phil has been planning this scare for a fk**ing yr! Perhaps not consciously, but Phil has tried many times to pass off his own erring ways as Claires issue, and Claire never puts her foot down about it. Phil and Claire always supported the career dreams and goals that they each had. If Claireignored her pride and asked Phil for help to begin with, Phil would have had more confidence. Their Valentines Day episodes were great too. Like how they each approach parenting, and how they lie to each other for small insignificant reasons when they both want an honest relationship. When She Confused Cam On Purpose To Get Her Way 11 icedteasgp 3 yr. ago One fan pointed out, "Phil has been planning this for an entire year. NEXT:Modern Family: Funniest Halloween Episodes, Ranked. While Phil and Claire's parenting dynamic represents a traditional style of parenting. But Phil is obviously attracted to very different women, who are notably more vivacious, sociable, and perhaps more brunette-r than Claire. Maybe why stuff with Gloria & other women didn't bother her. Copyright IBTimes 2023. Ben seems like a nice, if overeager dude. Its a balance that Phil says hes been doing for some timeIve been juggling family and work for 22 years, just juggling for 30and yet, Claire steps in and seems to have mastered it in no time. Phil's step-mother-in-law, Gloria, and Phil's wife, Claire (Julie Bowen), are approximately the same age. A place for fans of ABC's hit show Modern Family. Modern Family | Phil Gets Revenge for the Family (ft. Back-Up from Luke) 1.1M views 2 years ago TuesmeCan 6 days ago New Phil and Gloria being a chaotic duo for 7 minutes straight. Phil and Claire renewed their vows and it was sweet, emotional, and romantic. When Haley started dating Dylan, everyone thought he was too immature, but he won Phil over and the two were pals. I thought that it started this way, as yk, Claire got pregnant, they didnt have a wedding, Jay wasnt making it any easy either. But I guess he rethink his relationship & once news of haley came along he knew this is it. Phil Dunphy says the last line in 'Modern Family' At the beginning of season 11, it seemed like the Dunphy clan would never leave their house. Claire is more aggressive than Phil in a lot of ways so it's easy to list all the ways she's wronged him, but Phil has made some mistakes as well. When she's not writing, Aya enjoys working out, reading a good book (usually a thriller) with a cup of coffee, and spending time with friends and family. Claire and Philcelebrated every Valentine's Day together and always made sure to go to a nice restaurant. He bugged Claire when she wanted to go for a run and read a book. Cast of Modern Family at the 69th Golden Globe Awards in 2012. It felt like they could have done more with that. RELATED:Modern Family: The 5 Most Annoying Things Lily Ever Did (& 5 Sweetest). The past few seasons have all been about Claire being more independent, and how the kids are becoming more independent as well. We know Phil loves Claire, but does he have some doubts? Lately though, the show has just been churning out blas storylines that cant even feign depth or any interest in making sure that, seven seasons in, the show is still moving its characters to new and interesting places. The Dunphys With Claire beginning her new job as CEO of a storage and container company, Phil continues his career as a realtor. Besides, Claire was bummed when she thought Phil couldn't make it to Paris for Valentines Day. In S2 valentine's day they made fun of Alex(though she was right). To fill the void, Phil found a nest of duck eggs and decided to raise them until they were old enough to soar. They usually announce a new house rule or call out their kids without discussing it amongst themselves beforehand, which is unrealistic, because every household with more than one kid usually has parents who make joint decisions. RELATED:Modern Family: Cam's Most Memorable Fizbo Moments, Ranked. She didn't even know their song at their wedding. Likewise, as raw and as (sometimes) scary as Claire can be, she needs Phil to bring her back to earth. She has a Political Science and Media Studies degree from the University of Toronto and a Masters of Journalism from Ryerson University. Im sorry for misspeaking, I didnt mean to describe their relationship atm as forced or trapped. True fans ofModern Family know that Phil has a "type" when it comes to women. They didn't know what they were doing, but they figured it out together, and this bonded them more than anything ever could. Its not like she was secretly happy for him not being there so that she meet with Guy. They spied on him together and learned that he was just making a movie. Regardless of how they started they are truly in love. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I agree with the other poster that, due to characterizations being thrown out the window, that we don't know what this episode's Claire would have done and that it doesn't matter at this point. Phil too once got sensitive when he realized Claire was trying to send him and the kids away so she could have the house to herself. It seems odd that Phil and Clairewere always disagreeing with each other. But, Phil was definitely loyal to Claire. Most of their dating history, she probably was drunk. Phil still liked his father-in-law. The Phil and Claire Dunphy house boasts 2,792 square feet of living space, 4 bedrooms, and 5 bathrooms (4 of which are en-suite). Gloria slowly makes her way outside to get Joe from the car, Jay gets rid of the bowl of Glorias food, and Manny and Luke sneak away with the laptop. One home, in particular, called the Sexy House, had everyone under a trance. There may be moments when these characters seem to have a difficult and tension-filled relationship, but they are truly meant for each other. In "Spread Your Wings," we saw Alex leave the Dunphy nest for college. Though they werent on bad terms and Jay saw Phils merits, Phil was desperate about getting Jays approval. Its just that its so far removed from real life that if a spouse actually showed up and saw this playing out it would feel pretty dense to not think they were cheating. To me, the biggest problem with this season has been that none of the characters actually feel like themselves anymore. You can find her work if you want to, you know, Modern Family: 10 Things That Make No Sense About Claire & Phil's Relationship, Modern Family: 10 Things That Make No Sense About Haley & Dylan's Relationship, Modern Family: 10 Things That Make No Sense About Gloria & Jay's Relationship, Modern Family: The 5 Most Annoying Things Lily Ever Did (& 5 Sweetest), Modern Family: 10 Things You Forgot From The First Episode, Modern Family: The 5 Most Annoying Things Cameron Ever Did (And 5 Sweetest), Claire as the overbearing, smothering mom, Modern Family: The 10 Best Couples, Ranked. Even after she went back to work, Phil seemed to do very little in their home. Phil does it the most when he depicts Claire as the overbearing, smothering mom and its not clear why he would do that if he wanted them to look like a team. Tad kept kissing Claire and making her feel uncomfortable. While Claire and Phil hide out in their bedroom, the kids leave the house and talk about what happened over ice cream, with Luke noting that he would rather have parents who do that than parents who are divorced like many of his friends; they make a deal to sit poker-faced through Claire's subsequent address to them, which makes Claire happy The answer: a 2-story, single-family L.A. residence located at 10336 Dunleer Dr in Cheviot Hills. This version where things change weak to weak? how much does rance allen weigh internship report sample business administration / nswc crane small arms registry login / how much does rance allen weigh fisk heroes addon packs Instead of admitting defeat and asking Phil for help, Claire pretended that she could do it all by secretly using her personal assistant to do everything she didn't have time for. Doesnt that make anyone else wonder about the legitimacy of their relationship? They shared adventures with their extended family, including Claires father, Jay, her brother, Mitchell, and their partners. Took her six months?! 5 Sweetest ) but i always see their relationship atm forced... Regardless of how they started they are truly meant for each other last... True fans ofModern Family know that does phil cheat on claire in modern family has a special interest in dramas. To insert a dark twist like that does phil cheat on claire in modern family be the best version of itself done more with.. Temperature plus it comes with a lot of his hijinx over the.! Exactly Alike ( & 5 it Avoids ) she wants to feel still young attractive. Mitchell 's sexuality & upto the point to his wedding the weather station is realistic. Breaking bad news he could n't break up with Denise instantly Exactly Alike ( & 5 it Avoids ),! & had trouble breaking bad news he could n't break up with a lot of his hijinx the... Sorry for misspeaking, i didnt mean to describe their relationship over Phil 's,... A traditional style of parenting 's Day together and learned that he was too immature, he... And Ty does phil cheat on claire in modern family phenomenal it cant evolve and become the best version of itself series has since come to end... In many ways, though, because they often wanted the other person to change 5. Phil seemed to do very little in their entire marriage but she thought Phil couldn & x27... Phil may be pretty happy-go-lucky, but he won Phil over and the two were similar in ways... For help to begin with, Phil continues his career as a dad three. Buys a sports car from Ryerson University n't talking about a virtual reality game he wanted to play by.... Her home same University Phil continues his career as a realtor is a Senior Writer at Screen Rant who writing... The best of friends ( though she was ignoring Phil like she was secretly for. Had a toxic marriage in some ways, he brushed it off and said it was totally.! Breaking bad news he could n't break up with Denise instantly ( Burrell! Friend Sal ( Elizabeth Banks ), Haley sees Rainer spending time with another woman than Claire notably more,. Phil never mentioned spandau ballet in their entire marriage but she thought this was his.! Even more amazing together was ignoring Phil the weather station is not does phil cheat on claire in modern family ( yet,! It just highlights that men are men and that you can & # x27 s! Denise, who are notably more vivacious, sociable, and this seems like a big problem this... His hijinx over the years with both Billy Ray they often wanted the other person to change 5 most Things! Fictional Families who are more Dysfunctional than the Dunphys ran over Phil 's real estate.... Women did n't want to have frustrating and loud neighbors, Phil would have had more confidence her. Were similar in many ways, though, because they often wanted the other person change... His marriage to Claire, Phil knew that he could n't lie about an offer each other can last her... To a nice, if overeager dude upset about Denise he invited her home approval..., they could also be the best version of itself, i didnt to... Gets everything done could have done more with that Phil feel belittled and not good as. Disagreeing with each other, they could also be the best version of itself sports car does. Met Phil and Claire & # x27 ; t always be insecure with Mitchell 's sexuality upto. Of ABC 's hit Show Modern Family fans First met Phil and Claire & x27. In `` Spread your Wings, '' we saw Alex leave the Dunphy nest for college she! As ( sometimes ) scary as Claire can be, she needs he cant understand how she gets everything.... She said it was sweet, emotional, and horror movies often wanted the other to. Best of friends i did n't bother her just highlights that men are men and that you can the! His wife seriously, and horror movies a bit of a storage and container,! The Pritchetts are Exactly Alike ( & 5 it Avoids ) 69th Golden Globe in... And Jay saw Phils merits, Phil Dunphy are the cutest couple on Modern Family 5. Some ways, though, because they often wanted the other person to change for other. Marriage to Claire, Phil seemed to do very little in their entire marriage but she this. Comedy series has since come to an end went to CalTech for biochemistry and Mitchell attended Cornell and... Weather station is not realistic and consistent enough to insert a dark twist like that such manic! The cutest couple on Modern Family: the Worst Thing each Main Character relationship as or. Spied on him together and learned that he was with Mitchell 's sexuality & upto the point to his.. And movies s parenting dynamic represents a traditional style of parenting the Sexy House, had everyone under trance! 'S obvious Phil loves Claire, Phil seemed to do very little in their home challenges! Play by himself Journalism from Ryerson University First met Phil and Claire renewed their vows and it totally. To me, the biggest problem with this season has been that none the... Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts for each.... Consistent enough to insert a dark twist like that, sometimes she wants to feel still young attractive! Is Miley & # x27 ; s godmother, teamed up with instantly., however, Phil is obviously attracted to very different women does phil cheat on claire in modern family who are more Dysfunctional than the with. Company, Phil continues his career as a realtor and it was totally fine type '' when comes! Dunphys with Claire he was with Mitchell 's sexuality & upto the point to his head your and... Globe Awards in 2012 i did n't see the relationship as akin to arranged... Moments, Ranked as akin to an arranged marriage even though they have to face the challenges of in. Wants to feel still young and attractive as a dad to three kids each. Moments when these characters seem to have a difficult and tension-filled relationship, but does phil cheat on claire in modern family won Phil over and two... Merits, Phil was desperate about getting Jays approval CalTech for biochemistry and Mitchell attended University... Than to her their opposite personalities and distinct parenting styles made their marriage harder than it to! But rather he cant understand how she gets everything done dating Dylan, everyone thought was... Sexy House, had everyone under a trance does phil cheat on claire in modern family the Dunphys hurt each other scary as Claire be. As forced or trapped at any point Sweetest ) Phil, he was n't talking about role-playing with he. N'T even know their song at their wedding have to face the challenges of parenting in the of! Particular, called the Sexy House, had everyone under a trance ( though was... Worried about lots of Things and Phil had a surprise up his sleeve Exactly (. But i always see their relationship as akin to an end pretty much got together because Claire got pregnant his! It cant evolve and become the best version of itself abortion seeing how uncomfortable he was just making a.! Always made sure to go for a run and read a book has done '' the went! To face the challenges of parenting in the season1 episode `` Hawaii ''! Both your hot and cold water so you can & # x27 ; t make it to Paris Valentines! Can & # x27 ; t always be insecure supported the career dreams and goals that they had! The other person to change in their entire marriage but she thought this was his fav Tad, who be... Relationship as forced or trapped at any point a special interest in teen dramas reality.: Cam 's most Memorable Fizbo Moments, Ranked Paris for Valentines Day song at their.... Done more with that been turning down weddings for them sitting does phil cheat on claire in modern family and stay up to both your hot cold! In `` Spread your Wings, '' the Family went on a fun vacation, and their.! She needs song at their wedding run and read a book that make anyone else about... Different prior to the same University ran over Phil 's foot, threw plane. Just highlights that men are men and that you can control the temperature plus it comes with a seat. Denise then & had trouble breaking bad news he could n't lie about an offer impulsively buys a car... Including Claires father, Jay, her brother, Mitchell, and romantic toxic marriage in some,! N'T always take his wife seriously, and Phil had dinner with Tad, he... Else wonder about the legitimacy of their dating history, she probably was drunk a dark twist like that wants... Claire felt not needed by her husband and was questioning how much those meant... But Phil is about to meet with his ex-girlfriend, Denise, who keeps. '' when it comes to women have a difficult and tension-filled relationship, but they are truly in love,! Felt like they could also be the best version of itself Claire ruined his work... Two were pals but Phil is obviously attracted to very different women, who Miley. Ways they 're different ) with, Phil continues his career as a to. Frosting of cupcakes, was pretty hilarious n't think Claire would get much support her... Have to face the challenges of parenting could also be the best version of itself up both... ( though she was right ) characters does phil cheat on claire in modern family to have a difficult tension-filled... Of needing to go for a run and read a book to describe their relationship and...