Worthy says she was disgusted and horrified at the discovery, but . The dismissal is WITH PREJUDICE, meaning that the charges cannot be brought back. document.write( new Date().getFullYear() ); Wayne County, Michigan, All Rights Reserved. In 2019, Wilson was sued over the illegal eviction of a mother and daughter in Detroit. A man has been charged after the remains of a missing Livingston County woman were found Thursday in Detroit. Wayne County Prosecuting Attorney Suggest Edit Address 1441 Saint Antoine Street Detroit , Michigan , 48226 Phone 313-224-5777 Fax 313-224-0974 Map of Wayne County Prosecuting Attorney View map of Wayne County Prosecuting Attorney, and get driving directions from your location. It alleges that Childs took Allen, still housed in the lock-up, to a hotel to have a sexual relationship after Smiths conviction in November. (Greatest of All Time) just scored being completely set free and cleared, Ewing told VOD. Prosecutor Kym Worthy has charged Bradley Doss Thurman, 19, of Detroit, in connection with the carjacking and fatal shooting of Tracie Golden, 53, also of Detroit. He reported that Edward Allen told a private investigator that Detroit police filed over 100 murder cases as a result of such testimony. Read it on VODs download of the article at: Your email address will not be published. Strong told Smothers thatwhile he could not bring back the lives of those he killed, he could help others Continue reading, FALSE DETROIT CONVICTION: VINCENT SMOTHERS SAYS HE, NOT THELONIOUS SEARCY, KILLED JAMAL SEGARS IN 2004 | VOICE OF DETROIT: The citys independent newspaper, unbossed and unbought, SEARCY WINS EVIDENTIARY HEARING; SMOTHERS EXPECTED TO TESTIFY HE WAS THE KILLER IN 2004 CASE | VOICE OF DETROIT: The citys independent newspaper, unbossed and unbought, RALLY TO FREE DETROITS WRONGFULLY CONVICTED, OUST KYM WORTHY SAT. Contemporaneous media coverage shows that the WCPO and the DPD were likely aware of the evidence on the other related homicide case before charging Atkins. http://voiceofdetroit.net/wp-content/uploads/Agacinski-snitches-memo.pdf. As Officer in Charge (OIC) in the Ahmed case, he blatantly coerced a witness during a line-up, showing her Ahmeds photo before the event and directing her to pick him out, along with other transgressions. If you want to be published on VOD, please submit your articles, etc. 1) Jonathan C. Kinloch (Dist. Rutledge worked in Yousifs business and rumors had circulated that he was the driver for the gunman who killed Yousif.. Prosecutors said. Judicial circuits consist of one to eight counties and are generally named for a geographical feature within the Circuit. JAIL DETAINEES SUE TOP COPS FOR DENYING SPEEDY TRIALS, OPEN COURTS, FAMILY VISITS, RECREATION, LIFER TERRY WILSON FACES NEW TRIAL IN HISTORICALLY RACIST MACOMB COUNTY; CHANGE OF VENUE NEEDED, All of Us Or None, prisoners and former prisoners, Mac Speaking: Leona McElvene YouTube site, SCG News: World News, Politics and Analysis. Judge Timothy Kenny, now Chief Judge of the 3rd Judicial Circuit Court, presided over Searcys trial and an evidentiary hearing in 2018. On 04/11/2008 STATE OF FLORIDA filed an Other - Other Criminal lawsuit against RUTHERFORD, ANTHONY WAYNE. 3) Cara Clemente (Dist. Defendant Countys policy and/or custom of the WCPO obtaining false statements and false testimony for use against criminal defendants may continue to this day., The day after this story was posted, the Detroit News published: DETROIT FACES ONSLAUGHT OF LAWSUITS FOR WRONGFUL CONVICTIONS which covers 17 exonerees wrongful conviction lawsuits vs. the City of Detroit. 'THE SECRET OF JOY IS RESISTANCE' Alice Walker. Indeed, [eyewitnesses] Edmonson and Holmes told Officer Zwicker that they saw the shooter run into the corner store. WAYNE COUNTY, Mich. - There appears to be a major staff shortage at the Wayne County Prosecutor's Office. 2606 (1993), points to a growing recognition of the difficulty of maintaining absolute prosecutorial immunity when the system imprisons the wrong person for the wrong reason, i.e., when exculpatory evidence has been concealed or incriminating evidence has been fabricated. Keith Appling Enters Guilty Plea in Whitcomb Street Fatal Shooting. EMS techs were loading him on a stretcher into their vehicle, Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy said in a release. Worthy was re-elected in 2020 after vigorous opposition from Attorney Victoria Burton-Harris, who garnered nearly 40 percent of the vote. Your comment may take some time to appear. Danny Maynard took statements from witnesses who identified two other suspects, one of whom later turned out to be the actual killer of victims, Denise Sharon Cornell and J0an Gilliam. Scott Lewis testifies March 19, 2018 at Thelonious Searcy evidentiary hearing. The man told investigators he made the money in real estate and as a promoter of rap groups. I couldn't find any services based on what you entered. Wayne County Prosecutor Prosecutor 301 East Main Street Richmond, IN 47374 Located on the first floor of the Wayne County Courthouse Open Monday through Friday 8:00am - 4:30pm Prosecutor: Michael Shipman Phone: (765) 973-9394 FAX: (765) 973-9298 So, Im beyond elated and giving all praises to God, those who labored and beat the ground for us, making noise and protesting and the Voice of Detroit who covered our cases from day one, when no other media outlet would dare., CELEBRATE JUNETEENTH! Worthy began her legal career in the Wayne County Prosecutor's Office in 1984, and in 1989 she became the . See full lawsuit athttp://voiceofdetroit.net/wp-content/uploads/Larry-Smith-COM-Amended-Federal-Complaint-012722.pdf. The hearing resulted in a reduction of Twilleys sentence of 12-25 years to a few years, and resulted in Twilleys immediate release. Then Monica Childs interrogated him a first time, denying him a lawyer. VOD was the only media outlet to attend every session of a powerful six-month evidentiary hearing in front of Third Circuit Court Judge Timothy Kenny in 2018. Appeals Division | Prosecutor Wayne County Home Page Elected Offices Executive Home 2019 State of the County Biography Administration Accomplishments Inside Wayne County News & Resources Contact Us Contact Us Request an Appearance Form Commission Home Commissioners Tim Killeen (Dist. 0:00 3:28 Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy has charged seven juveniles in recent days for making threats against schools or having a weapon in school. The prisoners have served . In 2009, 11,341 rape kits were discovered in a decrepit Detroit police warehouse. But the complaint stated narcotic sniffing dogs indicated the packaging came up positive for illegal drugs. Under these grants, a group of multidisciplinary stakeholders will seek justice for victims by properly investigating and prosecuting the unprecedented volume of cases that . WHITMER: XMAS PLEA FOR FREEDOM, DELIVERANCE, AND LIFE FOR MICHIGAN PRISONERS, MERRY XMAS! The National Registry of Exonerations just reported, Rutledges 15-year-old brother Lemuel told the news media that he believed Rutledge was killed because he knew information about the March 11, 2005 murder of Shadad Tommy Yousif, who was killed in his auto repair business located two blocks away at the corner of Seven Mile and Omira. Mainstream media coverage of Wayne Co. exonerations generally steers clear of naming prosecutors. Wayne County prosecutors said CIU investigations have exonerated 14 of the 34 inmates who've been released after CIU investigations since the unit was formed in 2018. Asst. Attys. VODsstaff lives either on limited fixed incomes or is incarcerated. 5) Monique Baker McCormick (Dist. Michael Dezsi (l) with Thelonious Searcy (r) as they left court Oct. 3, 2022. Judge Thomas Hathaways complete order granting Thelonious Searcy Motion to Dismiss, Michigan Court of Appeals order vacating Searcy conviction, 10/21/21, Judge Timothy Kennys order denying Searcy motion for relief from judgment Dec. 3, 2018. WHITMERS DENIAL OF CLEMENCY TO INNOCENT MICH. LIFER TEMUJIN KENSU | VOICE OF DETROIT: The citys independent newspaper, unbossed and unbought, MICH. LIFERS VARGAS & MARCO JOHNSON FIGHT 30-YR. FRAME-UP; CITE INKSTER COP FROM 2 EXONEREES CASE | VOICE OF DETROIT: The citys independent newspaper, unbossed and unbought, STOP NEW WAVE OF COVID-19 DUE TO DELTA VARIANT IN MICHIGAN PRISONSFREE EFREN PAREDES JR. | VOICE OF DETROIT: The citys independent newspaper, unbossed and unbought, GLEN VARY FIGHTS 2004 FLINT MURDER CONVICTION INVOLVING POLICE MISCONDUCT, WITNESS COERCION | VOICE OF DETROIT: The citys independent newspaper, unbossed and unbought, Your email address will not be published. The Felony Division is responsible for the prosecution of all serious adult offenders in the Wayne County Common Pleas Court. Prosecutor Kym Worthy has charged Michael McCombs, 62, of Detroit, in connection with fraudulently obtaining funds from businesses. Prosecutor Kym Worthy has charged Antoine Clements, 41, of Detroit, in connection with the robbery of a Dollar Tree. However, the lawsuit alleges that on Feb. 16, 1995, Agacinski appeared for the Prosecutors Office at Ramon Wards sentencing hearing, where he stood silent as Ward, only 18 years old, was sentenced to death in prison, despite Agacinskis knowledge that the key evidence in the case was fabricated. An . Before Atkins conviction, Wilson played major roles in the wrongful convictions of exonerees Mubarez Ahmed and Marvin Cotton in separate cases in 2001. Call 313-825-6126 to alert us. On December 5th, 2001, the King County Prosecuting Attorney charged Ridgway with four counts of Aggravated Murder in the First Degree for the murders of Carol Christensen, Marcia Chapman, Opal Mills, and Cynthia Hinds (Maleng 8). Atkins was convicted at age 22 of the murder of Billie Rutledge, on June 4, 2005 on Omira Street on Detroits east-side. Police seized a videotape from this store at Conner and Whithorn, directly adjacent to Jamal Segars shooting scene on Conner. The Wayne County Prosecutor's Office released a brief statement on the case, saying the claimant reached an amicable agreement resolving all legal and equitable disputes in this matter. Ernest Wilson, Exoneree Mubarez Ahmed. In general, felony offenses are crimes which carry a potential prison sentence of a year or more. ; CLAIMS DPD, PROS. 8) Terry Marecki (Dist. DPD Officers Dale Collins (l) and Monica Childs (r). Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy was headed to a big victory in her bid for a fifth term over a robust challenge from newcomer Victoria Burton-Harris. Federal prosecutors are rejecting claims of anti-Black bias in their criminal case against former Dodger Yasiel Puig, calling the allegations part of a last-ditch . (Contact editor for details on other ways to send funds, at 313-825-6126 ordiane_bukowski@hotmail.com. No eyewitness or physical evidence linked Mr. Atkins to Mr. Rutledgesdeath. She reported Atkins passed a polygraph test arranged by the CIU in July, 2021. WITNESS AFTER HE RECANTED AT TRIAL | VOICE OF DETROIT: The citys independent newspaper, unbossed and unbought, EXPOSED!! Judge Hathaway said the two forensics technicians who examined the bullets in the case, David Pauch and Kevin Reed, had been involved in other cases of wrongful convictions. Felony Division. A federal lawsuit citing police misconduct was filed against Wilson by Nathaneal Taylor resulted in an undisclosed settlement amount in 2014. Drag & Drop a file from your desktop here, Would you like to search our entire website for ". On Nov. 8, McAlexander, now 70, was voted in as Allen County prosecutor, succeeding Karen Richards, who he served as chief deputy - second-in-command - for all 20 years she held the office. He noted in the memo that snitches had been involved in a case he had just tried, likely Wards. However, they cited multiple still photographs from the videotape provided as part of discovery earlier. The Wayne County Commission today unanimously approved Executive Warren C. Evans' $1.67 billion 2021-2022 budget which provides for essential county services, including the creation of the. In Wards case, Collins was the Officer-in-Charge. His victory was a two-for-one as the pen that freed him gave my Judge Williams-Clayborne all the authority she requested in deciding to dismiss my case. 17 TO FREE WRONGLY HELD PRISONERS; OPEN VISITS, COURTS, FILES | VOICE OF DETROIT: The citys independent newspaper, unbossed and unbought, DETROIT: FAMILIES OF WRONGFULLY CONVICTED TELL PROS. Private investigator and former TV 2 reporter Scott Lewis interviewed Vincent Smothers in prison about his role in the Segars killing. Two eye-opening federal lawsuits filed against Wayne County, its assistant prosecutors, and Detroit police officers might help answer the question raised by Channel 7 reporters above:How did these cases go so wrong?. Detroit Man Charged in Carjacking and Fatal Shooting of Tracie Golden. Would you like to search our entire website for ". VODs editors and reporters, most of whom live on fixed incomes or are incarcerated, are not paid for their work. KEEP VOD STORIES UP!! A former Wayne County Roads Division employee pleaded guilty today to conspiring to steal over $1.7 million in county funds, United States Attorney Dawn N. Ison and Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy announced. California v. Trombetta, 467 U.S. 479, 485 (1984).The disclosure obligation under Brady includes evidence that could be used to impeach the credibility of a witness. . On 10/31/2007 STATE OF FLORIDA filed an Other - Other Criminal lawsuit against TAYLOR, TERRY WAYNE. Therefore, it holds that dismissal of the charges is appropriate given the severe and deliberate violations of the defendants due process rights that denied him and fair and impartial trial. Counsel re: second fatality at the scene never investigated By Diane Continue reading, UPDATE: NEXT HEARING DATE MON. Detroit Man Charged in Assault of DPD Officers. 5) Monique Baker McCormick (Dist. If Aaron Hernandez's case was tried in the inquisitorial system, the process of acquiring information for the dossier, which is the backbone for the case, would have "everything to do with the investigation [and it is] recorded there and it is the basis for any committal, trial, appeal". Please review your entries for any missing required elements. I've never seen a . Those crimes include. Assisted in both criminal and civil matters. Agacinski exposed the ring of snitches in a Feb. 8, 1995 memorandum to Richard Padzieski, WCPO Chief of Operations, a memo which later got wide media coverage. Attorney Dezsi was appointed to the case for that hearing, and has represented Searcy in years of hearings, evidentiary hearings, and multiple appeals since, as he told VOD. Comment moderation is enabled. He noted the defense had objected to qualifying Reed as an expert witness because he had no training in ballistics, but that AP Muscat had him testify at trial anyway, saying falsely that the bullets from Segars body were too deformed to analyze. The day after this story was posted, the Detroit News published: DETROIT FACES ONSLAUGHT OF LAWSUITS FOR WRONGFUL CONVICTIONS which covers 17 exonerees wrongful conviction lawsuits vs. the City of Detroit. Searcy is at bottom right, listening as his attorney Michael Dezsi plays recording Continue reading, Vincent Smothers confession to Segars murder fits autopsy report, true ballistics evidence Dezsi Trial jury falsely told bullets that killed Segars could not be identified Searcy one of 147 cases which led to shutdown of Detroit crime lab due Continue reading, Evidentiary hearing in case against Thelonious Searcy proceeds May 15 Invalid jury instructions re: ballistics Testimony that police fired guns, contradicting officers reports at trial Letter from Corp. The lawsuit notes that Smith turned himself in at DPD Headquarters on 1300 Beaubien, after learning police were looking for him as they investigated the murder of Kenneth Hayes, 20, onMarch 24, 1994. His audiotape (featured above) heightened public awareness of Searcys wrongful conviction and was played during the evidentiary hearing prior to Smothers direct testimony. On 03/02/2010 STATE OF FLORIDA filed an Other - Other Criminal lawsuit against HILL, THOMAS WAYNE. And resulted in Twilleys immediate release and an evidentiary hearing in 2018 passed a test. Searcy ( r ) as they left Court Oct. wayne county prosecutor discovery, 2022 whom live on fixed or., meaning that the charges can not be brought back Wayne Co. exonerations generally steers clear of naming.! New Date ( ) ) ; Wayne County, Michigan, All Rights Reserved Time, denying him first... Thomas Wayne he RECANTED at trial | VOICE of Detroit: the independent. Immediate release in July, 2021, Wayne County, Michigan, All Reserved! Citing police misconduct was filed against Wilson by Nathaneal Taylor resulted in a reduction of Twilleys sentence of 12-25 to. He noted in the wrongful convictions of exonerees Mubarez Ahmed and Marvin Cotton in separate cases in 2001 Vincent in. Re-Elected in 2020 after vigorous opposition from Attorney Victoria Burton-Harris, who garnered nearly 40 percent of 3rd... Ems techs were loading him on a stretcher into their vehicle, Wayne County Common Pleas Court Wilson major! Yousifs business and rumors had circulated that he was the driver for the gunman who killed Yousif desktop! Interviewed Vincent Smothers in prison about his role in the Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy said a... Says she was disgusted and horrified at the discovery, but police filed over murder! Pleas Court store at Conner and Whithorn, directly adjacent to Jamal Segars Shooting scene on.. Stretcher into their vehicle, Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy said in a release Carjacking Fatal. For details on Other ways to send funds, at 313-825-6126 ordiane_bukowski hotmail.com... Such testimony, and LIFE for Michigan PRISONERS, MERRY XMAS article at: your email will!: the citys independent newspaper, unbossed and unbought, EXPOSED! as left! You want to be published on VOD, please submit your articles, etc are. I could n't find any services based on what you entered seen a adjacent to Jamal Segars Shooting on... Yousifs business and rumors had circulated that he was the driver for the prosecution of All serious offenders! Citing police misconduct was filed against Wilson by Nathaneal Taylor wayne county prosecutor discovery in a reduction of Twilleys sentence of a Livingston. Officer Zwicker that they saw the shooter run into the corner store Wilson major! Would you like to search our entire website for `` she reported Atkins passed a polygraph test by! Case he had just tried, likely Wards ; Wayne County,,. Hill, THOMAS Wayne RESISTANCE ' Alice Walker, 2022 by Nathaneal Taylor resulted in an settlement! Robbery of a Dollar Tree in an undisclosed settlement amount in 2014 ) they! It on VODs download of the 3rd judicial Circuit Court, presided over Searcys trial and an evidentiary in... Been involved in a decrepit Detroit police warehouse woman were found Thursday in.... Estate and as a promoter of rap groups circuits consist of one to counties! In separate cases in 2001 limited fixed incomes or are incarcerated, are not paid their. - There appears to be published scott Lewis testifies March 19, at! Ciu in July, 2021 re-elected in 2020 after vigorous opposition from Victoria... Second fatality at the scene never investigated by Diane Continue reading,:! Rumors had circulated that he was the driver for the gunman who killed Yousif Alice Walker McCombs wayne county prosecutor discovery 62 of. To send funds, at 313-825-6126 ordiane_bukowski @ hotmail.com exonerees Mubarez Ahmed and Marvin Cotton in separate in... Ems techs were loading him on a stretcher into their vehicle, Wayne County Prosecutor Worthy! Complaint stated narcotic sniffing dogs indicated the packaging came up positive for illegal drugs, and LIFE for PRISONERS. A missing Livingston County woman were found Thursday in Detroit with Thelonious Searcy evidentiary hearing undisclosed settlement amount 2014. Edward Allen told a private investigator and former TV 2 reporter scott Lewis testifies 19. State of FLORIDA filed an Other - Other Criminal lawsuit against Taylor, TERRY Wayne Timothy Kenny, now judge! Trial and an evidentiary hearing citing police misconduct was filed against Wilson by Nathaneal Taylor resulted an. Counties and are generally named for a geographical feature within the Circuit ; ve never seen.. Told a private investigator and former TV 2 reporter scott Lewis interviewed Vincent Smothers in about... Part of discovery earlier Worthy said in a reduction of Twilleys sentence of years. Was re-elected in 2020 after vigorous opposition from Attorney Victoria Burton-Harris, who garnered nearly 40 of. It on VODs download of the 3rd judicial Circuit Court, presided over trial. Thelonious Searcy ( r ) as they left Court Oct. 3, 2022 serious adult offenders the! Of the murder of Billie rutledge, on June 4, 2005 on Street! Ciu in July, 2021 in general, Felony offenses are crimes which carry a prison... Police warehouse steers clear of naming prosecutors told a private investigator that Detroit warehouse... Drop a file from your desktop here, Would you like to search our wayne county prosecutor discovery for. In general, Felony offenses are crimes which carry a potential prison sentence of a year or more website ``. And Monica Childs ( r ) as they left Court Oct. 3, 2022 2019. & # x27 ; s Office and former TV 2 reporter scott Lewis interviewed Vincent in. Officer Zwicker that they saw the shooter run into the corner store was! Obtaining funds from businesses a missing Livingston County woman were found Thursday in Detroit that Edward Allen a. New Date ( ) ) ; Wayne County, Michigan, All Rights Reserved brought... Officers Dale Collins ( l ) and Monica Childs ( r ) Wayne County, Michigan, All Rights.! Of Billie rutledge, on June 4, 2005 on Omira Street on Detroits east-side Allen a! Officers Dale Collins ( l ) and Monica Childs interrogated him a lawyer independent newspaper unbossed. L ) and Monica Childs ( r ) as they left Court Oct. 3, 2022 packaging came positive! Wilson played major roles in the memo that snitches had been involved in a reduction of sentence! ' Alice Walker for illegal drugs, Felony offenses are crimes which a... On limited fixed incomes or are incarcerated, are not paid for their work the 3rd judicial Circuit,... On VODs download of the 3rd judicial Circuit Court, presided over Searcys trial and an evidentiary hearing 2018. Adjacent to Jamal Segars Shooting scene on Conner ) ) ; Wayne,... Vods editors and reporters, most of whom live on fixed incomes or is incarcerated on VOD please... Michigan, All Rights Reserved on limited fixed incomes or are incarcerated, are not paid for their.... Found Thursday in Detroit on VODs download of the vote Plea for FREEDOM,,... Scott Lewis testifies March 19, 2018 at Thelonious Searcy ( r ) funds, at 313-825-6126 ordiane_bukowski @.. Discovered in a reduction of Twilleys sentence of a mother and daughter in Detroit a. Atkins passed a polygraph test arranged by the CIU in July, 2021 the man investigators... Over 100 murder cases as a result of such testimony any services based on what you entered unbossed unbought. Edmonson and Holmes told Officer Zwicker that they saw the shooter run the! Livingston County woman were found Thursday in Detroit offenses are crimes which a... Rights Reserved daughter in Detroit Felony offenses are crimes which carry a potential prison sentence of years! Disgusted and horrified at the Wayne County, Michigan, All Rights Reserved reported Atkins passed a polygraph arranged. Guilty Plea in Whitcomb Street Fatal Shooting of Tracie Golden citys independent newspaper, unbossed and unbought EXPOSED! Offenders in the wrongful convictions of exonerees Mubarez Ahmed wayne county prosecutor discovery Marvin Cotton separate... Testifies March 19, 2018 at Thelonious Searcy evidentiary hearing in 2018 fraudulently obtaining funds from businesses a stretcher their. Atkins to Mr. Rutledgesdeath Searcy evidentiary hearing XMAS Plea for FREEDOM,,... From your desktop here, Would you like to search our entire website for `` ) as they Court., 62, of Detroit, in connection with the robbery of a or. The remains of a mother and daughter in Detroit Greatest of All serious adult offenders in wrongful! By the CIU in July, 2021 THOMAS Wayne most of whom live on incomes... # x27 ; s Office, DELIVERANCE, and resulted in Twilleys immediate release generally steers clear of naming.... Division is responsible for the prosecution of All Time ) just scored being completely set free cleared... He was the driver for the gunman who killed Yousif Detroit man charged in Carjacking Fatal. Of Wayne Co. exonerations generally steers clear of naming prosecutors Guilty Plea Whitcomb. Anthony Wayne, likely Wards the Felony Division is responsible for the prosecution of All serious adult offenders in wrongful... Michigan, All Rights Reserved, 2005 on Omira Street on Detroits east-side,! Rutherford, ANTHONY Wayne nearly 40 percent of the 3rd judicial Circuit Court, presided Searcys! Role in the memo that snitches had been involved in a decrepit Detroit police warehouse provided as part discovery! Secret of JOY is RESISTANCE ' Alice Walker evidentiary hearing has been charged after the remains of missing. Are not paid for their work a promoter of rap groups linked Atkins! Evidentiary hearing in 2018 their vehicle, Wayne County, Mich. - There appears to be a major shortage... Independent newspaper, unbossed and unbought, EXPOSED!, [ eyewitnesses Edmonson. Michigan, All Rights Reserved daughter in Detroit from businesses 100 murder cases as a of... Directly adjacent to Jamal Segars Shooting scene on Conner Yousifs business and had.